The Yankee offense coughed this one up, although you could blame Mariano Rivera and Damaso Marte (Rasner did what he could as a back-end starter). The club is just squandering opportunities to move up in the standings. On a night that had the Red Sox facing John Lackey (who nearly threw a no-hitter) and the Rays facing Roy Halladay, you would think the offense would show up today, but they didn’t. And, when they finally decided to show some signs of life, it was the 9th inning and the game was over.
With that said, I can’t just blame the players. Let’s not forget that Joe Girardi, of course, deserves some of the blame here (some is the key word). Here’s a list of things he did wrong.
1. First, Joe Girardi has said that the first game of the series is the most important one to win. Well, sorry Joe but the Yankees lost the first game, so wouldn’t it be as important to win the second (pivotal) game, in order to split the series? That’s important too, right? Apparently it’s not because Xavier Nady got the night off. Now, I understand that Nady was struggling since his arrival, but, he hit a homer last night and was needed in the lineup today. Maybe that HR was a sign that he was breaking out, you never know (we’ll never know). I don’t think it’s going to kill him to have him in there in the second game, which could dramatically effect the series’ outcome. If you want to sit him, sit him in the third game, once you’ve split the series, OR, sit him in the next series (again, I don’t think he’ll be hurt if you play him for 2 more days). Also, let’s not forget that Jason Giambi had been slumping hard coming into today’s game. Wouldn’t you want to keep the lineup as deep as possible to help him and everyone else around him?
2. Moving on, Joe Girardi loves his splits. After Darrell Rasner struggled, he brought in Damaso Marte to face Nick Markakis. Now, when this happened, I nearly threw a punch into my computer screen (I watch MLBTV). I know about Nick Markakis because I have him on a few fantasy teams, but that doesn’t mean I’m the only one nor does it mean it’s hard to learn a thing or two about him. Markakis hits lefties this year at a phenomenal clip. In fact, his .317 AVG and .956 OPS against them are better than his righty-splits. Joe Girardi could have easily learned this if he would have looked at a scouting report, or a statistics page. But no, Girardi sees a lefty and calls a lefty. He doesn’t ask questions. He doesn’t check the numbers, he simply reacts and that’s that. He called in Marte to face Markakis and Markakis promptly singled and loaded the bases. Girardi could have brought in Edwar or Veras to face him since it would have been a better battle. Then he could have brought in Marte to face Huff (who doesn’t hit lefties well). When is Joe going to learn that not all lefties do poorly against lefties (and vice versa)? Of course, it’s up to Marte to execute, but still.
3. My final complaint is minor. Why is Richie Sexson on this team? Wilson Betemit cannot hit lefties as right-handed hitter, so why not give Sexson a pinch hit? He was brought in to hit lefties, right? That was the reasoning? Granted, he’s terrible, but that’s why you brought him in. He probably would have struck out, but Betemit hits .229 against lefties this year. Hell, if Girardi is a numbers guy, I think Sexson’s .338 AVG against lefties earns him a shot (even if it is an aberration). At least he’s shown some more patience against them in comparison. I just don’t get Sexson’s presence on this team. If you want defense, you can get that elsewhere (and it’ll actually be GOOD). Just because Sexson is cheap, doesn’t make him worth it, especially if he’s even good enough to pinch hit against a left-handed pitcher.
As you can see, Girardi should get SOME of the blame (he is the manager, after all). He didn’t put his best lineup out there and he hurt the team before the game even started. Then, when the game started, some of his moves were rather questionable. I don’t think I’m being harsh, am I?