Dunn, Pat Burrell, Bobby Abreu, Mark Teixeira — any of those potential free agents would lift the Indians’ sagging offense. Teixeira, the only plus defender, is by far the most appealing. Then again, as badly as the Tribe is going, a little creativity might be required.
Dunn and Burrell would be difficult fits; neither can play right field, and their defensive shortcomings would partly offset their offensive contributions.
Teixeira would not be available unless the Braves were desperate for starting pitching and positioned to deal for a suitable replacement at first base.
Abreu? An interesting thought, considering that the acquisition of Sabathia would give the Yankees exclusive negotiating rights with the pitcher until he reached free agency. But the Indians surely would want more than a fading 34-year-old right fielder for a 28-year-old ace.
Second baseman Robinson Cano, 25, would be more intriguing, but the Yankees can control Cano through 2013 and would not trade him unless they received younger pieces such as left-hander Aaron Laffey and outfielder Ben Francisco in addition to Sabathia. For the Indians, who need young players to balance their payroll, such a deal would be self-defeating.
OK, what about Abreu to satisfy short-term objectives plus one or two of the Yankees’ better young pitchers to satisfy long-term needs?
Such possibilities are worth exploring, at the very least.
Trading Sabathia for multiple prospects only would make sense if the Indians fell out of contention, which is unlikely in the surprisingly mediocre AL Central.
But keeping Sabathia, then losing him for draft picks, only would make sense if the Indians looked poised for a World Series run. At the moment, they hardly resemble that kind of a team.
As of now, the Yankees seem like they could use a right-handed bat instead of a left-handed ace, but then again, it’s a 28 year old left-handed ace, so who wouldn’t want that? If such a trade were to occur (Ian Kennedy is starting to look expendable), the Yankees could shift their outfielders if they wanted to play Matsui at LF or give Shelley Duncan a shot at an everyday job in RF.
Unlikely but interesting.