
Everyone is wondering why Mike Mussina pitched to Manny Ramirez last night. Let’s face it, it was a stupid move by Mussina and he and the Yankees paid for it. Moose, although one of my favorite Yankees, has always been a rather stubborn type when he takes the ball. You can see it whenever he challenges someone with back-to-back fastballs, fastballs which gently touch 87 mph on the gun (if he’s lucky). It is his ability to concede and acknowledge his loss of stuff that has allowed him to succeed thus far in 2008. Tonight, we saw what happens when Mussina gets greedy.
Mussina momentarily forgot, essentially, who he is and what he’s capable of. To give him credit, I think Moose pitched a lot better than what the box score might indicate. He had some tough hits in the first inning (one by Pedroia comes to mind) and he really had only 2 bad pitches tonight (both of them were, unfortunately, hit very hard by Manny Ramirez). Also, to play devil’s advocate a bit and to defend Mike Mussina, Kevin Youkilis is off to a hot start, hitting .317, and he would have faced Mussina with the bases loaded if Moose walks Manny. He’s also a .294 hitter against him.
Moose figured he’d take a chance with Manny, get ahead with a pitch on the outside part of the plate, and then toss him junk until the cows came home. Youkilis doesn’t chase that junk at all and neither does Manny, really, but he’ll go after it a bit more than Youkilis will. Again, I’m not trying to substantiate Mussina’s move, I’m just trying to go along with his thinking process.
Either way, it didn’t work. Hopefully, next time he’ll swallow his pride and walk the damn guy.