Yahoo’s baseball experts decided to get together and predict the 2008 baseball season. I didn’t read every one of their predictions, but I did manage to read each of their AL East predictions and wow, I must ask, what world are these guys living in?
Below is Steve Henson’s prediction. I’d like to talk about each person’s prediction, but they’re essentially the same, as each predicts the Sox over the Yankees for the same reasons (one guy even says the Blue Jays will overtake the Yankees):
Late March adventures in the Tokyo Dome and the L.A. Coliseum might cause the Red Sox to start slow, but this is one of the best rosters in recent memory. Better than the Yankees, who are counting heavily on young pitchers and aging position players, and the Blue Jays, whose team doctor should be MVP if they win the division. The Rays are improving but are still middle-school level to the Red Sox graduate students.
So, let’s see here. They have a better roster because the Yankees are “counting heavily on young pitchers and aging position players…” Hmm, this concept has been talked about endlessly by many sportswriters, analysts, and of course, fans. However, is this statement truly accurate? Let’s look at the rosters.
The Red Sox have the following starting lineup: Jacoby Ellsbury (24), Dustin Pedroia (24), Kevin Youkilis (29), David Ortiz (32), Manny Ramirez (36), Mike Lowell (34), J.D. Drew (32), Jason Varitek (36) and Julio Lugo (32). Their SP’s are Josh Beckett (28), Dice-K (27), Jon Lester (24), Tim Wakefield (41), Clay Buchholz (22).
The Yankees have the following starting lineup: Melky Cabrera (23), Robinson Cano (25), Jason Giambi (37), Hideki Matsui (34), Johnny Damon (34), Alex Rodriguez (32), Bobby Abreu (34), Jorge Posada (36) and Derek Jeter (34). Our SP’s are Wang (28), Andy Pettitte (36), Phil Hughes (22), Mike Mussina (39), Ian Kennedy (23).
If you look at the ages provided above, exactly where is the big difference? The Red Sox have 6 hitters playing on the wrong side of 30 (32+) and the Yankees have 7. One of those 7 was actually the AL MVP last year. The Yankees have offensive consistency up and down the lineup. Can you really say that with the Red Sox? What can you expect from Varitek, JD Drew, or Julio Lugo? Now what about the pitching? I see both teams relying upon their young arms this season, not just the Yankees. What was Henson talking about? Also, last time I checked (uh, just now), the Yankees actually have more experience in their rotation than the Red Sox.
Please, everyone, stop the madness already.










