Mark Feinsand did a good job and asked Jeter about the old “Jeter’s defense is getting worse every year and will inevitably have to switch to another position” theme. The Captain had some interesting comments in response:
One recent University of Pennsylvania study tabbed Jeter as the worst defensive shortstop in the majors, but the Yankees’ captain has no plans to pull a Robin Yount or Ernie Banks and shift positions for the latter years of his career.
Instead, he plans on playing shortstop through the final three years of his current contract, and on remaining there for however many years he plays beyond 2010.
“That’s the plan,” Jeter said. “I haven’t really thought about how long I’m playing. I take it one year at a time; I don’t sit down and say, ‘Well, I hope I’m playing in two-thousand whatever.’ It’s a tough question, because I haven’t really thought about it much.”
Could Jeter, who has been named to eight American League All-Star teams in his 12 big-league seasons – four as the league’s starting shortstop – ever see himself playing another position?
“Right now?” Jeter said, “No.”
He didn’t necessarily shoot down the concept, altogether. He essentially said that for now, this is what he’s doing and this is where he’ll play. It could change later on, but that transition is still fairly far off in the horizon. Jeter still thinks he can play well defensively (which I think is somewhat debatable, although the stats don’t ”lie”), despite that UPenn study which really got a tremendous amount of media coverage.
So what position would Jeter play if he didn’t play SS? Obviously he’s not going to be behind the plate. I’ve stated before that Jeter could possibly be a good outfielder and that he may even be a valuable asset at first base. Mark Feinsand elaborates a bit more.
Many scouts believe Jeter would be able to make an easy transition to the outfield, where his speed, strong arm and terrific instincts would make him a natural. Asked about the possibility, Jeter waves off the question before it’s finished.
Recently, Buster Olney (ESPN) offerred a similar evaluation as well.
Jeter, who turns 34 this summer, has reached the stage of his career where he will be evaluated year to year at shortstop, and if he regresses from how he played the position last year, he may well be asked to move, to first base or the outfield. Personally, I think he would be better suited at first base than in the outfield, whenever he makes a move off shortstop, and could become an excellent first baseman.
It’s an interesting idea, moving Jeter to first or to the OF. It’s all debatable and a position switch definitely makes sense when you think about it (not necessarily now, but later). However, exactly how practical is this idea, and what does Jeter think about it. Well, Feinsand got to hear about that too. Here’s what Jeter had to say about a switch.
“Hopefully, I don’t have to think about that for quite some time,” Jeter said.
Oh, okay. Well, how about playing the outfield Derek?
“I ain’t going out there,” Jeter said. “It’s not as easy as it sounds to just pick up a glove and say, ‘I’m going to be an outfielder today.’ It doesn’t work like that.”
For all of those who think Jeter should move to another position one day, maybe we have to come to the realization that it just won’t happen. Olney states that Jeter is being evaluated, defensively, “year to year at shortstop”. However, when Joe Girardi speaks about Jeter and his abilites at SS, he seems ready to keep Jeter there for the rest of his career (or at least for the rest of his managerial tenure).
“The thing about a guy like Derek Jeter is that it’s hard to envision him not playing,” Girardi said. “There is going to come a day when he’ll retire, but in my mind, it’s too far out so I don’t really see it. Maybe if he’s playing at 47, he won’t be a shortstop.”
So, we can argue about Jeter’s defense all we want. At the end of the day, the man will be manning that position for years. He could even be there beyond 2010. What’s amazing about this whole situation is that the UPenn study really caused all of this. It’s pretty interesting how quickly it became mainstream knowledge (even though it’s highly statistical) and Jeter himself had to actually respond to it.
You think he’s bitter?
As for his current position, Jeter feels he’s a better shortstop now than he was during the early years of his career thanks to experience. By making the necessary adjustments on a regular basis, Jeter is constantly addressing what he feels are his strengths and weaknesses in the field. Just don’t ask him what those are.
“I’ll leave that to the computers to figure out,” he said with a grin.
Hmmm, yeah, I think he’s a little bitter…