
What will the Yankees do with Jason Giambi this season? Platoon at first with Shelley Duncan? Let him play until he wins a gold glove hurts himself? Will they slot him in as the regular DH? These are all questions that need to asked and are surely a thorn in the side of many within the Yankee offices. Granted, Giambi could probably put up decent numbers and his OPS will be around .800, but he’s still a $22 million question mark.
The Yankees could easily give Giambi the DH role, fulltime. However, this would prove to be problematic with Hideki Matsui sitting on the bench. The team wants all the offense it could muster (it takes pressure off the younger pitchers), so if the Yankees pursue this route, there would have to be a tremendous juggling act in order to give these guys playing time. Also, who will play first base with Giambi off the field for good? Do you really feel comfortable with a suspect platoon while Hideki Matsui rots on the bench?
My suggestion is very simple. Why not let Giambi play first until he falls apart? It sounds sort of mean, but it’s probably the best solution. You could put Giambi in the lineup as DH, where he has a career line of .246/.385/.476 or you can slot him in as the first baseman (everyday) and hope that his career line of .309/.433/.575 runs its course for as long as possible before he leaves the field with some stupid injury (note-I’m guessing these numbers are inflated due to Giambi’s “enhanced” years, but you get the point). Once the injury pops up, then stick with the platoon. If he comes back partially healthy, just keep the platoon going with him and Shelley Duncan (instead of… Ensberg?).
This move would also free up the DH slot for Hideki Matsui who has proven his effectiveness in this role. In fact, Matsui’s career DH line of .308/.382/.555 is not only an adequate replacement for Giambi’s line (as a DH), but it’s actually better than Matsui’s line as a regular in LF (although the sample size is considerably smaller). With this configuration, you’d have Damon in LF, Matsui at DH, and Giambi at 1B. This would prove to be the best offensive lineup possible, so why not just do it?
That’s not to say that Giambi or Damon can’t slot into the lineup as a DH. With the normal configuration demonstrated above, Girardi could also tinker with the lineup in order to provide guys with ample rest. He could put Matsui in LF on some days, allowing Damon to get some rest as the DH. He could also have Giambi slot in as DH on some days and either give Damon a chance at first (he tried last year) or throw in a role player.
I’m sure that Giambi will give up runs at first. That’s almost guaranteed. But, I’m sure that the entire team, being the offensive juggernaut that it is, can ultimately move past those errors and runs. Giambi will probably get hurt, true. But, again, who cares? He’s done after this year and as long as we get enough production from him to justify a fraction of his cost, then putting him on the field doesn’t really sound too bad.
In order for it (Giambi as a regular player in the field) to be a practical option, it all comes down to what Girardi thinks. In the past we’ve heard Giardi values defense:
“I always value defense,” Girardi said. “I think defense is very important, because you can save a lot of runs, as well as drive in a lot of runs. So we will look at those things as the season goes on, but it’s very important to me.”
This quote was from a few months ago. Has Girardi switched his tone knowing that the best offense would have Giambi on the field, everyday? Well, he may have done just that. Here’s some new information from our old friend Peter Abraham.
Cashman has no plans to pursue a first baseman via trade. The answer, he said, will come from within. Giambi could have an edge, since Girardi believes he would be a more productive hitter if he plays in the field.
So, in the end, let’s let the guy play until his limbs fall off. He’s about as mobile as a patch of moss, but having him at first would help the team’s offense considerably.